IHG's "Quality Compounder" Story Sounds Great. Here's What It Means If You're Actually Running One of Their Hotels.
Berenberg just slapped a buy rating on IHG and called it a quality compounder. Wall Street loves the stock. But the numbers underneath tell a very different story depending on which side of the management agreement you're sitting on.
Let me tell you what caught my eye this week. Berenberg comes out with a glowing report on IHG... "quality compounder," "accelerated growth," buy rating with a $157 price target. And look, on paper, the story is clean. 16% adjusted EPS growth in 2025. Over $1.1 billion returned to shareholders. A record 443 hotel openings. Net system growth of 4.7% for the fourth consecutive year of acceleration. If you're an IHG shareholder, you're having a great week.
But here's the number that should be tattooed on every franchisee's forehead: Americas RevPAR was up 0.3% in 2025. Zero point three. And Q4? U.S. RevPAR was actually down 2%. So the company is posting 16% EPS growth while the hotels generating the fees are essentially flat or declining on a per-room basis. That's the magic of asset-light, folks. The franchisor's earnings are compounding beautifully while the owner's top line is treading water. Same P&L, two completely different stories depending on which line you stop reading at.
I've seen this movie before. I sat in an owner's meeting once... must have been 15 years ago... where the brand rep was celebrating "record system growth" while half the room hadn't seen a RevPAR increase in 18 months. One owner in the back raised his hand and said, "That's great. My lender doesn't care about your system growth. He cares about my debt service coverage ratio." Room went quiet. That tension between franchisor prosperity and franchisee reality isn't new. But it's getting louder. IHG is projecting 4.4% net unit growth for 2026 while simultaneously launching yet another collection brand (the Noted Collection, targeting conversions) and pumping the loyalty program past 160 million members at 66% contribution. Those are impressive franchise-level numbers. The question is whether the individual hotel owner sees enough of that loyalty contribution to justify what they're paying for it.
And about those conversions... 52% of IHG's 2025 openings were conversions. More than half. That's not organic growth. That's rebranding existing hotels with new signs and new fee structures. Some of those conversions will genuinely benefit from the IHG system. Some of them are owners who got sold a loyalty contribution number that looked great in the pitch deck and will look different 24 months from now. I've watched enough franchise sales presentations to know that the projected loyalty contribution and the actual loyalty contribution are often two very different numbers. And by the time you find out which one you got, you've already signed the agreement and spent the PIP money.
Here's what nobody's telling you about the "quality compounder" narrative. It works precisely because IHG doesn't own the hotels. They collect fees on the way up and they collect fees on the way down. When RevPAR drops 2% in Q4 like it did, IHG's fee income barely flinches because system size keeps growing. But at your property? That 2% decline hits your GOP directly. Your labor didn't get 2% cheaper. Your insurance didn't drop. Your property taxes didn't go down. The $950 million buyback program IHG just announced for 2026? That's funded by franchise fees and loyalty assessments from hotels where the GM is trying to figure out how to staff breakfast with two fewer people than last year. I'm not saying IHG is doing anything wrong. They've built an excellent business model... for IHG. The question every owner should be asking is whether it's an excellent model for them.
If you're an IHG franchisee and your owner is reading this Berenberg report thinking "great, our brand partner is thriving"... sit them down and walk through YOUR numbers. Pull your actual loyalty contribution percentage versus what was projected at signing. Calculate your total brand cost as a percentage of revenue (fees, assessments, PIP amortization, mandated vendors... all of it). If you're north of 18% and your RevPAR was flat or negative last year, that's a conversation you need to have now, not at renewal. And if you're an independent owner being pitched an IHG conversion right now, get the actuals from comparable properties in your comp set. Not the projections. The actuals. There's a filing cabinet somewhere with the truth in it.